Roads End Naturalist

Exploring the natural world as we wander at the end of the road


Learning New Leps

·

Happiness is like a butterfly; the more you chase it, the more it will elude you, but if you turn your attention to other things, it will come and sit softly on your shoulder.

~Henry David Thoreau

I was pretty good at identifying the common species of butterflies (in the Order Lepidoptera (which means scaly wings) back in NC although the skippers continued to baffle me at times. But now I must learn almost an entirely new set of the flying flowers. We don’t yet have a lot of Montana native wildflowers on our little lot but early on we were seeing a few species of butterflies flapping by the house. And that is exactly what they did – flapped by the house, most without even a brief stop for a photo or closer look. One of the first ones I noticed was a familiar-looking butterfly – a large yellow and black swallowtail, but which one? A tattered individual finally landed on a leaf in our yard one cool morning and a I snapped a couple of pics of a worn two-tailed swallowtail.

The aptly named two-tailed swallowtail reminds me of our yard in NC which would swarm with Eastern tiger swallowtails every few years. The host plants of this species include ash and chokecherry. (click photos to enlarge)

One day a very boldly-marked medium sized butterfly made an appearance in the yard. I grabbed my camera and snapped two photos before it flitted away.

A gorgeous Weidemeyer’s admiral taking a break in the yard

Weidemeyer’s admirals are related to the red-spotted purple butterflies we had back in NC. The caterpillars of both species resemble bird droppings.

We have an irrigation system for our few flower beds and when the soil is damp, it seems to attract some butterflies that may be looking for mineral salts. This beauty showed up one morning and I was lucky enough to get a good photo before it flew off.

A stunning checkerspot butterfly (I think it is either an Edith’s or Anicia’s checkerspot) dabbling in the moist soil of a flower bed in our yard.

My identification routine is to use two apps – SEEK and Leps, to try to identify. I then check my only field guide for this region – Butterflies of Grand Teton and Yellowstone National Parks. After that, I submit the observation to iNaturalist and see if I can get any confirmation of my initial ID. Well, it seems as though these Western species may be a bit tougher than I’m used to and the apps often disagree or just aren’t sure. One reason is the large number of very similar-looking butterflies, especially the checkerspots and frittilaries. Here are some examples.

An Edith’s checkerspot on a trail near Mammoth
A relict frittilary. Most of the frittilaries use violets as their host plants. This species apparently overwinters as a caterpillar.
It seems some of the frittilaries are best identified by their underwings. iNaturalist tells me this one is a Mormon frittilary
These butterflies were very abundant along a nearby Forest Service dirt road this week nectaring on the abundant rabbitbrush in bloom. I identified this one as a Zerene frittilary, but there are a couple of others it could be

I hope you see what I mean by all these look-alikes (at least to my untrained eye). I may be totally wrong but I am relying on iNaturalist primarily until a reviewer disagrees. If any of you know about these species and have a correction, please let me know in the comments.

Another brownish and patterned small butterfly – a field crescent I believe

I think this one is a Northern crescent

I have seen fewer skippers than I am use to back in NC. Those are the small, often cryptically colored little butterflies that zip around making it even tougher to ID them. They are distinguished from oter groups of butterflies by most having small hooked tips at the end of their antennae. I think I have seen three species of skipper here thus far and many of them have been the introduced Essex skipper which was very abundant earlier in the summer.

A dainty American branded skipper on rabbitbrush this past week
A mating pair of Essex skippers
I saw another mated pair of butterflies, this time one of the frittilaries, but they were flying by (somewhat clumsily as you might imagine based on their positions) and finally dropped to the ground allowing this one photo.

Of course, with all that mating going on, there was also some egg laying. I saw this next species a few times doing the typical fluttery flight that females do when they are looking for a host plant. I followed this one around for several minutes as it landed and crawled on the ground. It occasionally assumed the egg laying position of a tucked abdomen. But I was confused as I didn’t see a living plant nearby (this was on a dry ridge at high elevation with sparse ground cover and scattered clumps of grasses). After much searching, I finally found an egg on a dried plant stem. It started me wondering if the egg is the overwintering stage. Back home, I looked up this species, the Rocky Mountain Parnassian, and found that my field guide stated that females lay a single egg “randomly” (another reference said she lays the eggs haphazardly). Further reading showed they lay on just about anything – rocks, leaf litter, twigs, and other plant species near their host plants. Their host plant is stonecrop, a low growing plant growing in dry open habitats. The eggs typically overwinter and the larvae hatch shortly after being exposed to warm temperatures in the spring. The caterpillars then crawl and locate a host plant.

A female lays an egg on a dry plant stem
Here is a Rocky Mountain Parnassian caterpillar feeding on stonecrop (Sedum lanceolatum) in early June. The sedum dies back in winter and resprouts from its base the following spring.

There are a number of small-ish challenging butterflies that I have tried to photograph . The ones that have eluded me the most are a few (not sure if I am seeing multiple species or not) small white ones. I guess I will need to catch a few next summer to truly ID them. There is a local citizen science butterfly count each July organized by a nearby neighbor who is an excellent naturalist, author, and sculptor. I missed it this year since we were in the Tetons with family but I will definitely get it on my schedule next year to learn from some local experts.

A small blue butterfly was one of the first I tried to identify. I believe it is a Boisduval’s blue whose larvae feed on lupine.
One of the clouded sulphurs, perhaps a pink-edged sulphur.
This species blended into the bare soil extremely well, making it hard to track once it landed. This pic was taken in the Beartooth Mountains at an elevation of over 9000 feet. Caterpillars of this species with the unusual name, Chryxus Arctic, require two years to develop. Because of this, in many regions, you only see the adult butterflies every two years.
I recognized this as some sort of satyr by its lilting flight and the drab coloration marked by distinctive eye spots on the hind wings. This is a small wood nymph, and several were out nectaring on the rabbitbrush this week.
The thicket hairstreak spends most of its time high in the treetops and comes to the ground to nectar on flowers or dabble in moist soil (as this one was doing). The larval host plant is dwarf mistletoe which occurs on various species of conifers.
The irregular wing outline identified this as one of the so-called anglewings, a favorite group of mine back in NC. This is a green comma and like its cousins in the East, it has a silvery white punctuation mark (a comma) on the underside of its wings.

While hiking in the Beartooths back in July, I spied this next beautiful butterfly flitting about at the base of a talus slope. It kept flying away from me so I gave the camera to Melissa who was closer to where it was nectaring. She got this great shot of one of the most beautiful species we have seen in Montana, a Milbert’s tortoiseshell.

Its genus name, Aglais, is from from the Greek name, Aglaia, which means “splendor,” “brilliance,” or “beautiful”. They overwinter as adults so may be seen on any warm days throughout the year. Milbert’s tortoiseshells are thought to undergo seasonal elevational migrations, spending summers at higher elevations. Females lay clusters of eggs (up to several hundred) on the underside of the host plant (mainly stinging nettles). (photo by Melissa Dowland)

I continue to stalk insects and spiders on every walk we do, grabbing a few pics and posting to iNaturalist. Hopefully, by next summer I’ll have a greater knowledge and appreciation for the many invertebrates we have as neighbors in our new surroundings. I encourage you to get out and learn about your wild neighbors, especially the small ones. They are the backbone of the natural world we live in and the more you learn, the more you will want to preserve them and their habitats.

Comments

7 responses to “Learning New Leps”

  1. David Hord Avatar
    David Hord

    Beautiful Mike. We have spotted the first Monarchs that we have seen in our yard last week.

    1. Mike Dunn Avatar

      Thanks, David. Miss seeing those monarchs and their caterpillars!

  2. maggiejeanw Avatar
    maggiejeanw

    Loved reading your NC blog and still love it.

    1. Mike Dunn Avatar

      Thank you. We were hoping people would still follow us on our new adventures and learnings.

  3. Steve Prentice-Dunn Avatar
    Steve Prentice-Dunn

    Thank you, Mike. Looks like a lot of beiges, browns, and oranges in your neck of the woods. As usual, your photos give us a great close-up.

    Steve

  4. Nik Avatar
    Nik

    Hi Mike,

    I tried to leave a comment on this last week, but it looks like it disappeared into the ether.

    Great photos, especially the skippers.

    I was thinking if you ever get really stuck on a lep ID, you might want to reach out to this guy:
    https://www.colorado.edu/cumuseum/dr-ryan-st-laurent

    I’m sure if he can’t help, he could refer you to someone who could.

    Also the CU Museum is apparently closed until Jan. 8, 2026, but it’s worth a visit if you’re in the area.

Leave a comment

Roads End Naturalist

Exploring the natural world as we wander at the end of the road

Copyright Mike Dunn and Melissa Dowland